PONARS Eurasia
  • About
    • Contact
    • List of Members
  • Policy Memos
    • List of Policy Memos
  • Podcast
  • Online Academy
  • Events
    • Past Events
  • Recommended
Contacts
Address 1957 E St NW, Washington, DC 20052 adminponars@gwu.edu 202.994.5915
NEWSLETTER
Facebook
Twitter
YouTube
Podcast
PONARS Eurasia
PONARS Eurasia
  • About
    • Contact
    • List of Members
  • Policy Memos
    • List of Policy Memos
  • Podcast
  • Online Academy
  • Events
    • Past Events
  • Recommended
DIGITAL RESOURCES
digital resources

Bookstore 📚

Knowledge Hub

Course Syllabi

Point & Counterpoint

Policy Perspectives

RECOMMENDED
  • COVID-19 in Eurasia: PONARS Eurasia Policy Perspectives

    View
  • Preparing for the Parliamentary Elections of 2021: Russian Politics and Society (Gel’man, Lankina, Semenov, Smyth, and more)

    View
  • Russians supported Putin’s moves in Crimea in 2014. Here’s what’s different in 2021

    View
  • Putin’s Rules of the Game: The Pitfalls of Russia’s New Constitution

    View
  • In the Caucasus, There Is a Peace Agreement but Not Peace

    View
RSS PONARS Eurasia Podcast
  • Music and Politics in Contemporary Russia [Lipman Series 2021] April 12, 2021
    In this week's PONARS Eurasia Podcast, Maria Lipman chats with Alexander Gorbachev about the dynamic music scene in contemporary Russia, and how free Russian musicians are to make political statements.
  • How is the Russian Government Coping with Rising Food Prices? [Lipman Series 2021] March 15, 2021
    In this week's PONARS Eurasia Podcast, Maria Lipman chats with Anton Tabakh about rising food prices in Russia, and what they might mean for Russia's current and future stability.
  • The Communist Party of the Russian Federation: More Than Just Systemic Opposition? [Lipman Series 2021] March 5, 2021
    In this week's episode of the PONARS Eurasia Podcast, Maria Lipman chats with Felix Light and Nikolay Petrov about the contemporary Communist Party of the Russian Federation, including the divisions between its leadership and membership, its attitude toward Alexei Navalny, and why it might be more than just "systemic" opposition after all.
  • Internet Resources: Civic Communication and State Surveillance [Lipman Series 2021] February 16, 2021
    In this week's PONARS Eurasia Podcast, Maria Lipman chats with Andrei Soldatov and Tanya Lokot about the role of the internet in contemporary Russian politics, including both as a tool of the Russian opposition and as an instrument of the increasingly repressive Russian regime.
  • The Rise of Alexei Navalny's Political Stature and Mass Protest in Russia [Lipman Series 2021] February 1, 2021
    In the first PONARS Eurasia Podcast of 2021, Maria Lipman chats with Greg Yudin about the current protests taking place in Russia, and what Alexei Navalny's growing popular support means for the Putin regime.
  • Russian Social Policy in the COVID-19 Era [Lipman Series 2020] December 21, 2020
    In 2020’s final episode of the PONARS Eurasia Podcast, Maria Lipman chats with Sarah Wilson Sokhey and Ella Paneyakh to discuss Russian social policy in the COVID-19 era, and public perception of Russia’s overall pandemic response.
  • Conscious Parenting Practices in Contemporary Russia [Lipman Series 2020] December 10, 2020
    In this week's episode of the PONARS Eurasia Podcast, Maria Lipman chats with Julia Yuzbasheva and Maria Danilova to learn more about the proliferation of "conscious parenting" practices in contemporary Russian society.
  • The Transformation of Belarussian Society [Lipman Series 2020] November 11, 2020
    In this episode of the PONARS Eurasia Podcast, Masha Lipman chats with Grigory Ioffe about the long-term and short-term factors that led up to the current protests in Belarus, and the ongoing transformation of Belarussian society.
  • Russian Lawmakers Adjust National Legislation to the Revised Constitutional Framework [Lipman Series 2020] October 26, 2020
    In this week’s PONARS Eurasia Podcast, Maria Lipman chats with Ben Noble and Nikolay Petrov about ongoing changes to Russia’s national legislation based on the recently revised constitutional framework, and what these changes portend for the 2021 Duma election.
  • Russia's Regional Elections [Lipman Series 2020] September 25, 2020
    In this week’s PONARS Eurasia Podcast, Maria Lipman chats with Graeme Robertson and Konstantin Gaaze about Russia’s September 13 regional elections and whether or not the Kremlin should be worried about upcoming Duma elections.
  • Policy Memos | Аналитика

Masked Diplomacy: Xi and Putin Seek Advantage and Cover from the Pandemic

  • April 1, 2020
  • Elizabeth Wishnick

(PONARS Eurasia Policy Memo) In the United States, President Donald Trump claims to be a wartime president, while denying any responsibility as the country proved unprepared to confront its most serious health emergency in more than a century. American voters will soon have a chance to weigh in on his leadership. In China and Russia, however, we see authoritarian strongmen with an indefinite hold on power taking cover from bad news of the pandemic’s impact on their countries while seeking to take advantage of disorganized global and regional responses to the pandemic for short-term political gain. Given the outstanding questions about the handling of the pandemic in both China and Russia, such strategies may backfire in the long term and raise questions about their role in regional integration strategies.

Where was Xi?

As the world grapples with the COVID-19 pandemic, which may have originated as early as mid-November 2019 in Wuhan, the Chinese government is now seen as seeking to take advantage of lagging global responses to claim global and regional leadership. Rather than a display of Chinese strength, efforts to reframe the country’s role reveal an effort to shore up President Xi Jinping’s reputation after Chinese authorities suffered unprecedented criticism for their own initial slow response and attacks on early whistleblowers.

During the first few weeks of January, Xi was nowhere to be seen. The Chinese president did not visit the virus epicenter, Wuhan, until March 10, as the disease appeared to be weakening in the area. To counter such narratives, on February 26, Xinhua heralded the publication of a new book about Xi’s outstanding leadership during the pandemic. A French publication reported that Chinese embassies all over the world have been tasked with refuting that the virus began in China and to claim instead that the true origin of the virus remains unknown.

Chinese news outlets and officials have put forth a variety of outlandish origin stories, claiming that the virus began in Italy or was the product of a U.S. Army biological war attack. This led Chinese Ambassador to the United States Cui Tiankai to criticize such claims made by his colleagues at the Chinese Foreign Ministry, including spokesman Zhao Lijian, as “crazy” and “harmful.” All of this is occurring as Chinese officials gear up for the rescheduled opening sessions of their national legislature and a key advisory body, which may happen in late April or May. One of the reasons for the initial delay in reporting the outbreak of the virus in Wuhan may have been efforts by local officials to hide bad news prior to the January 12, 2020 opening of the provincial legislative session, a preparatory meeting for the national session.

Putin and Russia’s Response

China is not alone is spreading disinformation about the origins of the pandemic. According to an EU report, Russia has been doing this as well, in keeping with its ongoing efforts to sow distrust in Europe and the United States. Conspiracy theories about U.S. responsibility for the virus are also targeted at Russian audiences to deflect blame in case the pandemic becomes more extensive at home. Like Xi, President Vladimir Putin sees the pandemic as a threat to his own personal power, which he has recently sought to institutionalize in an April 22 referendum (now postponed indefinitely) regarding constitutional changes extending his term as president. Just as Xi made Prime Minister Li Keqiang the face of China’s response, so has Putin largely left it to other officials, his Prime Minister Mikhail Mishustin and Moscow Mayor Sergei Sobyanin, to manage the pandemic.

Russia claims to have relatively few cases (2,337 cases and 17 deaths as of March 31) and is only now taking serious steps to stem its spread. After the city of Moscow and the Moscow region announced a lockdown on March 30, 16 regions, mostly in European Russia, followed suit the same day. To enforce quarantines, newly developed facial recognition technology, widely used in China to identify regime opponents, has been deployed. Ironically, Chinese citizens were among the first to be targeted by Russian authorities using the technology, leading to official Chinese protests about discriminatory treatment of Chinese citizens in Russia. In February, the city of Zhengzhou, some 300 miles north of Wuhan, began using facial recognition gates and infrared temperature checks in all subway stations. A Chinese tech company has just developed the capability to detect faces even through masks (though the addition of sunglasses still vexes the system).

Experts claim that Russia has suspiciously few reported cases of COVID-19. There may be some underreporting in Russia, but other countries on China’s northern and western borders thus far have relatively few cases compared to other countries. All closed their borders to China without delay, strategic partnerships notwithstanding. While Central Asian countries now are seeing increased cases of COVID-19, this is from the second wave of the pandemic, reflecting travel from Europe not from China. The Russian map of the spread of COVID-19 (see Figure 1) shows a concentration of cases in European Russia, not along the border with China.

Figure 1. Cases of Coronavirus in Russia

Source: BBC (screenshot), March 31, 2020; data: Russian Government Communication Center

a

The Pandemic and Regional Partnerships

Some analysts project that COVID-19 is likely to undermine the Sino-Russian partnership—in the Russian media, as in the White House, some refer to the pandemic as the “Chinese coronavirus.” Nonetheless, even on the pandemic response we see a familiar pattern in Sino-Russian relations: mutual support by Xi and Putin, contrasted with ambivalence in Russian regions, as some local authorities target Chinese nationals in enforcing quarantines, while others bemoan the loss of Chinese visitors. We see similar trends in Kazakhstan and Mongolia, where top-level goodwill is maintained at the same time as trade is halted and quarantines are enforced.

Although Belt and Road projects have been suspended in Eurasia, China is only increasing its leverage on its key regional partners. The pandemic coincides with a dispute between Russia and Saudi Arabia over oil prices, further weakening the economies of resource-producing states like Russia and Kazakhstan. Nonetheless, Russian officials and analysts now see the coronavirus as a bigger threat to the Russian economy than the decline in the price of oil. Putin has taken some initial steps to bolster the Russian economy but much depends on the length of the pandemic since 60 percent of Russia’s trade is with Europe and China. Nonetheless, the Russian President has also capitalized on a disjointed response to the pandemic in Europe to show the Russian flag in Italy, sanctions notwithstanding. Russian sent nine planeloads of aid along with 100 troops, leading to criticism that Putin was playing “viruspolitik.”

As China claims to see few new cases of COVID-19 (though some dispute Chinese figures), Chinese agencies and companies are now offering assistance to a number of affected countries. With train connections newly built for the Belt and Road now idle, Xi announced that 110,000 masks and 776 gowns would be sent to Spain by rail (taking 17 days). The Chinese leader now speaks of “the health Silk Road”  connecting China with partners in the struggle against COVID-19. It remains to be seen what the long-term consequences of this outreach will be and its impact on China’s soft power in the future. In the immediate region, it is more likely that the experience with COVID-19 will make publics in Eurasia even more wary of regional connectivity than previously, creating a deeper disconnect between the messaging by the primarily authoritarian leaders and their more skeptical publics, who were already anxious about BRI projects leading to a greater influx of Chinese workers and leasing of property.

Conclusion

Rather than portending a new Chinese effort at global and regional leadership, COVID-19 reveals its absence and shows how poorly equipped global architecture is for 21st-century threats. No country or institution—not the United States, China, Russia, the UN, or the EU—has stepped up to craft a truly response that would provide a template for cooperative action and preventive measures for the health security crises of the future that are sure to come. Instead, the Chinese leadership, Putin’s government, the Trump administration, and others seek to assign blame to deflect attention from their own domestic shortfalls. China and Russia may seek to take advantage of a leadership vacuum, but they did not create it, nor do they have the soft power resources to overcome it.  It is democracies in Asia like South Korea and Taiwan who are to be emulated, as their strategies to contain COVID-19 proved effective as well as commensurate with democratic ideals of transparency and accountability.

Elizabeth Wishnick is Professor of Political Science at Montclair State University and Senior Research Scholar at the Weatherhead East Asian Institute at Columbia University.

[PDF]

Homepage image credit.

Memo #:
643
Series:
2
PDF:
Pepm643_Wishnick_April2020.pdf
Elizabeth Wishnick
Elizabeth Wishnick
Website | + posts
Professor, Department of Political Science and Law; Senior Research Scholar
Affiliation

Montclair State University; Columbia University
Links

Montclair State University (Bio)
Expertise

China, Central Asia, Energy, Environment, Migration, Public Health
  • Elizabeth Wishnick
    https://www.ponarseurasia.org/members/elizabeth-wishnick/
    China and Russia: Vaccine Competitors or Partners?
  • Elizabeth Wishnick
    https://www.ponarseurasia.org/members/elizabeth-wishnick/
    Reading the Soy Leaves: What Soybean Imports Say about China's 2020 Election Preferences
  • Elizabeth Wishnick
    https://www.ponarseurasia.org/members/elizabeth-wishnick/
    Mining for Trouble: The Resources at Stake in the China-India Border Dispute
  • Elizabeth Wishnick
    https://www.ponarseurasia.org/members/elizabeth-wishnick/
    Pipeline "Khanfluence": Power of Siberia 2 to Go Through Mongolia to China
Related Topics
  • 2020
  • China
  • Coronavirus
  • Russia
  • Wishnick
Previous Article
  • Recommended | Рекомендуем

When Local Corruption Goes Global: The Internationalization of Uzbekistan’s Telecom Bribery Scandals

  • March 31, 2020
  • Alexander Cooley
View
Next Article
  • Recommended | Рекомендуем

Cooley: Turkmenistan likely anticipates a post-pandemic economic collapse

  • April 2, 2020
  • PONARS Eurasia
View
You May Also Like
View
  • Policy Memos | Аналитика

China’s Expanding Military Education Diplomacy in Central Asia

  • Erica Marat
  • April 19, 2021
View
  • Policy Memos | Аналитика

This Time is Different (Again): The Political Consequences of the Economic Crisis in Russia

  • Andrei Semenov
  • April 1, 2021
View
  • Policy Memos | Аналитика

The Dzerzhinsky Discord: Who Will Fill the Vacancy in Lubyanka Square?

  • Maria Lipman
  • March 19, 2021
View
  • Policy Memos | Аналитика

The Political Consequences of Public Relations Miscalculations: Will Ukraine’s Anti-corruption Bureau be Terminated?

  • Ivan Gomza
  • March 12, 2021
View
  • Policy Memos | Аналитика

The Belarus Protests and Russia: Lessons for “Big Brother”

  • Natalya Chernyshova
  • March 1, 2021
View
  • Policy Memos | Аналитика

Central Asian Responses to COVID-19: Regime Legitimacy and [De]Securitization of the Health Crisis

  • Mariya Omelicheva and Lawrence P. Markowitz
  • March 1, 2021
View
  • Policy Memos | Аналитика

COVID-19 in Russia: What Russians Expected, What They Got, and What They Think About It

  • Sarah Wilson Sokhey
  • February 22, 2021
View
  • Policy Memos | Аналитика

The Russian Parliament and the Pandemic: A State of Emergency, Post-constitutional Changes, Retaliatory Laws

  • Ekaterina Schulmann
  • February 16, 2021
PONARS Eurasia
  • About
  • Membership
  • Policy Memos
  • Recommended
  • Events

Permissions & Citation Guidelines

Input your search keywords and press Enter.