PONARS Eurasia
  • About
    • Contact
    • List of Members
    • Ukraine Experts
    • About Membership
    • Executive Committee
  • Policy Memos
    • List of Policy Memos
    • Submissions
  • Podcast
  • Online Academy
  • Events
    • Past Events
  • Recommended
  • Ukraine Experts
Contacts

Address
1957 E St NW,
Washington, DC 20052

adminponars@gwu.edu
202.994.5915

NEWSLETTER
Facebook
Twitter
YouTube
Podcast
PONARS Eurasia
PONARS Eurasia
  • About
    • Contact
    • List of Members
    • Ukraine Experts
    • About Membership
    • Executive Committee
  • Policy Memos
    • List of Policy Memos
    • Submissions
  • Podcast
  • Online Academy
  • Events
    • Past Events
  • Recommended
  • Ukraine Experts
DIGITAL RESOURCES
digital resources

Bookstore 📚

Knowledge Hub

Course Syllabi

Point & Counterpoint

Policy Perspectives

RECOMMENDED
  • Illiberalism and Public Opinion Junctures in Russia’s War on Ukraine

    View
  • Policy Exchange Discussion & Memos: Guaranteeing Ukraine’s Long-Run Security (June 9)

    View
  • Ukraine’s Best Chance for Peace

    View
  • We want the war to end. But should calls for negotiating with Putin be taken seriously?

    View
  • Policy Briefs | BEAR Network-PONARS Eurasia Conference

    View
RSS PONARS Eurasia Podcast
  • The Putin-Xi Summit: What's New In Their Joint Communique ? February 23, 2022
    In this week’s PONARS Eurasia Podcast, Maria Lipman speaks with Russian China experts Vita Spivak and Alexander Gabuev about the February meeting between Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping, and what it may tell us about where the Russian-Chinese relationship is headed.
  • Exploring the Russian Courts' Ruling to Liquidate the Memorial Society January 28, 2022
    In this week’s PONARS Eurasia Podcast, Maria Lipman chats with scholars Kelly Smith and Benjamin Nathans about the history, achievements, and impending shutdown of the Memorial Society, Russia's oldest and most venerable civic organization, and what its imminent liquidation portends for the Russian civil society.
  • Russia's 2021 census and the Kremlin's nationalities policy [Lipman Series 2021] December 9, 2021
    In this week’s PONARS Eurasia Podcast, Maria Lipman chats with social scientist Andrey Shcherbak about the quality of the data collected in the recent population census and the goals of Vladimir Putin's government's nationalities policy
  • Active citizens of any kind are under threat [Lipman Series 2021] November 5, 2021
    In this week’s PONARS Eurasia Podcast, Maria Lipman chats with Alexander Verkhovsky about the Kremlin's ever expanding toolkit against political and civic activists, journalists, and other dissidents.
  • Russia's Legislative Elections followup [Lipman Series 2021] October 4, 2021
    In this week’s PONARS Eurasia Podcast, Maria Lipman chats with Tanya Lokot and Nikolay Petrov about the results of Russia’s legislative elections and about what comes next.
  • Why Is the Kremlin Nervous? [Lipman Series 2021] September 14, 2021
    In this week’s PONARS Eurasia Podcast, Maria Lipman chats with Ben Noble and Nikolay Petrov about Russia’s September 17-19 legislative elections, repressive measures against electoral challengers, and whether to expect anything other than preordained results.
  • Vaccine Hesitancy in Russia, France, and the United States [Lipman Series 2021] August 31, 2021
    In this week's PONARS Eurasia Podcast episode, Maria Lipman chats with Denis Volkov, Naira Davlashyan, and Peter Slevin about why COVID-19 vaccination rates are still so low across the globe, comparing vaccine hesitant constituencies across Russia, France, and the United States.  
  • Is Russia Becoming More Soviet? [Lipman Series 2021] July 26, 2021
      In a new PONARS Eurasia Podcast episode, Maria Lipman chats with Maxim Trudolyubov about the current tightening of the Russian political sphere, asking whether or not it’s helpful to draw comparisons to the late Soviet period.
  • The Evolution of Russia's Political Regime [Lipman Series 2021] June 21, 2021
    In this week's episode of the PONARS Eurasia Podcast, Maria Lipman chats with Grigory Golosov and Henry Hale about the evolution of Russia's political regime, and what to expect in the lead-up to September's Duma elections.
  • Volodymyr Zelensky: Year Two [Lipman Series 2021] May 24, 2021
    In this week's episode of the PONARS Eurasia Podcast, Maria Lipman chats with Sergiy Kudelia and Georgiy Kasianov about Ukrainian President Zelensky's second year in office, and how he has handled the political turbulence of the past year.
  • Recommended | Рекомендуем

The Elections and Kazakhstan’s Foreign Policy: Continuity But For How Long?

  • June 25, 2019
  • Nargis Kassenova

The Elections and Kazakhstan’s Foreign Policy: Continuity But For How Long?

Foreign policy was not at center-stage during the 2019 presidential elections in Kazakhstan. The main candidate, Kassym-Jomart Tokayev, selected by Nursultan Nazarbayev and endorsed by the ruling Nur Otan party, pledged to continue the “multi-vector” pragmatic balancing approach practiced for three decades of the country’s independence. However, a closer look at the programs of other candidates and the statement by the ad hoc People’s Assembly (Halyk kurultayi) movement reveal views on a desirable foreign policy and ways of interacting with the world that diverge from the official one.

Candidate Tokayev’s Take On Foreign Policy

Two out of seven presidential candidates articulated foreign policy approaches in their platforms—Kassym-Jomart Tokayev and Amirzhan Kosanov. Tokayev predictably won the elections. Kosanov, in a major surprise to many, including himself, gained a respectable 16 percent of the vote.

Tokayev has been in the higher echelons of power since early independence. He is a trained diplomat who twice served as Kazakhstan’s Foreign Minister. Thus, Tokayev can be described as the shaper and executor of the country’s pragmatic “multi-vector” foreign policy composed of balancing partnerships with great powers—Russia, China, the U.S., and the E.U., and integrating the national economy into regional and global markets. Despite his special expertise in international affairs, his election platform does not contain foreign policy, it just states continuity with the current policies developed by Nazarbayev, further strengthening the strategic partnerships with Russia, China, the U.S., Central Asian states, the E.U., East Asia and the Middle East, and attracting foreign investments.

Prior to the elections, in his capacity as interim President, Tokayev made an official visit to Moscow. He was accompanied there by the most powerful figures in Kazakhstan’s political scene, such as the Chair of the National Security Committee Karim Massimov. The goal of the visit was to show respect to the state’s most important strategic partner and possibly reach some agreement on a power transition.  

In the meantime, Nazarbayev visited Bejing for the 2nd Belt and Road Forum, serving as some sort of “proxy” of the new president.

At the end of May, Tokayev had a meeting with the President of the European Council Donald Tusk touring the region in the aftermath of the adoption of the new E.U. strategy for Central Asia and assured him of Kazakhstan’s determination to deepen relations. Nonetheless, his government’s highly problematic conduct during the elections which consisted, of electoral manipulations, an Internet blockade and mass arrest of protestors and random passersby, mire these prospects.

Candidate Kosanov’s Take On Foreign Policy

Unlike Tokayev, Kosanov does not have much expertise in foreign affairs. He is a journalist by training. In 1994-97, he served as Press Secretary of Prime Minister Akezhan Kazhegeldin (currently in exile), and since then he has been in various democratic opposition movements and parties. However, despite the lack of expertise in the area, he provides a more concrete set of ideas. Kosanov proposes to make the European Union as the main vector of Kazakhstan’s foreign policy.  He does not explain this choice, but it logically links with his central agenda of the promotion of human rights and democracy. It can also be traced to the platform of the 2005 united opposition presidential candidate Zharmakhan Tuyakbay that also defined the E.U. vector in Kazakhstan’s foreign policy as its main goal, as it was the best fit for providing long-term security and prosperity of the country.

Kosanov insists that all international agreements and treaties should be open to public scrutiny and suggests reviewing all agreements with transnational corporations on the use of natural resources. The latter is a populist demand that has been a staple of opposition across the spectrum from left to right. He adds to the demand to stop the practice of receiving “uncontrolled” foreign credits. This can be interpreted as a reference to China, the primary source of loans over the past decade.

Kosanov’s other demand and promise is to provide for national, military, economic, ideological, and information security of Kazakhstan and make the country truly independent. The economic, ideological and information security of Kazakhstan is usually discussed in the context of its relations with Russia. There is discontent with the leadership’s decision to join the Customs and Eurasian Economic Union with Russia. It is perceived as undermining the country’s national interest. There are also concerns about Russian media dominance in Kazakhstan’s information space and the Kremlin’s capacity to carry out hybrid warfare.

Thus, Kosanov’s foreign policy section is inspired by a mix of liberal democratic ideals and nationalist sentiments. It is not a developed policy program, but it contains linkages between domestic and foreign policy not characteristic by the Nazarbayev-Tokayev’s approach.

Vox Populi: People’s Assembly Resolution

Kosanov’s temperate agenda allowed for his inclusion in the elections as an alternative candidate, which made him a proxy for the protest vote. More radical opposition representatives did not have this chance. However, we can find their discourses outside the formal campaign. An important outlet for more radical views was the ad hoc People’s Assembly (Halyq kuryltayi) that gathered hundreds of activists from different parts of the country to discuss the elections. It featured such high-profile participants as cosmonaut and former deputy of the Majilis of the Parliament Toktar Aubakirov and former Secretary of the Security Council and Deputy Prime Minister Baltash Tursumbayev.

The Assembly adopted a resolution that included demands for political reforms, but also a legislative ban on selling and renting land to foreigners, a resolution on the situation with ethnic Kazakhs in Xinjiang, a limit on economic and trade relations with China, and the rejection of investment and credit from China. Fear of China’s growing presence and influence, and anger at the mistreatment of Kazakhs in Xinjiang, have been increasingly hot issues across the country. In 2016, Kazakhstan saw protests against legislation extending the term of land rent to foreign-owned companies that resulted in the government’s moratorium on it, until the end of 2021.

Concluding Remarks

During the first three decades of independence, Kazakhstan’s foreign policy was shaped by President Nazarbayev. It was driven by geopolitical considerations and neoliberal ideals of economic development. The elections and debates surrounding them give a taste of the growing linkages between domestic and foreign policy. Foreign policy issues play a more prominent role in local politics, and efforts to keep control over an increasingly awake society negatively affect Kazakhstan’s international reputation. If domestic politics becomes more competitive, the continuity of Kazakhstan’s foreign policy should not be taken for granted.

 

Nargis Kassenova
Website | + posts
Senior Fellow, Davis Center for Russian and Eurasian Studies
Affiliation

Harvard University
Links

Davis Center, Harvard University (Bio), KIMEP University (Bio)
Expertise

Central Asian and Asian Security, Eurasian Geopolitics and Energy
  • Nargis Kassenova
    https://www.ponarseurasia.org/author/nargis-kassenova/
    How Will U.S. Policy toward Central Asia Look under the Biden Administration?
  • Nargis Kassenova
    https://www.ponarseurasia.org/author/nargis-kassenova/
    Central Asia and the EU Connectivity Strategy: Rising to the Good Governance Challenge
Previous Article
  • Recommended | Рекомендуем

A Schizophrenic Mixture of Repression and Appeasement Marks Executive Succession In Kazakhstan

  • June 25, 2019
  • Dinissa Duvanova
View
Next Article
  • Point & Counterpoint
  • Recommended | Рекомендуем

Velvet Gloves Versus Iron Fist: Dilemmas of Control Under Russian Authoritarianism

  • June 26, 2019
  • Vladimir Gelman
View
You May Also Like
View
  • Recommended | Рекомендуем

Illiberalism and Public Opinion Junctures in Russia’s War on Ukraine

  • Sarah Wilson Sokhey
  • June 21, 2022
View
  • Recommended | Рекомендуем

Policy Exchange Discussion & Memos: Guaranteeing Ukraine’s Long-Run Security (June 9)

  • PONARS Eurasia
  • June 3, 2022
View
  • Recommended | Рекомендуем

Ukraine’s Best Chance for Peace

  • Samuel Charap
  • June 2, 2022
View
  • Recommended | Рекомендуем

We want the war to end. But should calls for negotiating with Putin be taken seriously?

  • Jordan Gans-Morse
  • June 1, 2022
View
  • Recommended | Рекомендуем

Policy Briefs | BEAR Network-PONARS Eurasia Conference

  • PONARS Eurasia
  • May 25, 2022
View
  • Recommended | Рекомендуем

The Baltic States Are Also Worried About Russia

  • Ralph Clem and Erik Herron
  • May 19, 2022
View
  • Recommended | Рекомендуем

International Society Must Act in the Wake of Russia’s Failed Opposition

  • Robert Orttung
  • May 12, 2022
View
  • Recommended | Рекомендуем

The Collapse of the Soviet Union | PONARS Eurasia Online Academy

  • PONARS Eurasia
  • May 12, 2022

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

PONARS Eurasia
  • About
  • Membership
  • Policy Memos
  • Recommended
  • Events
Powered by narva.io

Permissions & Citation Guidelines

Input your search keywords and press Enter.