PONARS Eurasia
  • About
    • Contact
    • List of Members
    • Ukraine Experts
    • About Membership
    • Executive Committee
  • Policy Memos
    • List of Policy Memos
    • Submissions
  • Podcast
  • Online Academy
  • Events
    • Past Events
  • Recommended
  • Ukraine Experts
Contacts

Address
1957 E St NW,
Washington, DC 20052

adminponars@gwu.edu
202.994.5915

NEWSLETTER
Facebook
Twitter
YouTube
Podcast
PONARS Eurasia
PONARS Eurasia
  • About
    • Contact
    • List of Members
    • Ukraine Experts
    • About Membership
    • Executive Committee
  • Policy Memos
    • List of Policy Memos
    • Submissions
  • Podcast
  • Online Academy
  • Events
    • Past Events
  • Recommended
  • Ukraine Experts
DIGITAL RESOURCES
digital resources

Bookstore 📚

Knowledge Hub

Course Syllabi

Point & Counterpoint

Policy Perspectives

RECOMMENDED
  • The Baltic States Are Also Worried About Russia

    View
  • International Society Must Act in the Wake of Russia’s Failed Opposition

    View
  • The Collapse of the Soviet Union | PONARS Eurasia Online Academy

    View
  • Labor Migration in Russia | PONARS Eurasia Online Academy

    View
  • Did Russia Put Its Geopolitical Glasses Back On? It Never Took Them Off in the First Place

    View
RSS PONARS Eurasia Podcast
  • The Putin-Xi Summit: What's New In Their Joint Communique ? February 23, 2022
    In this week’s PONARS Eurasia Podcast, Maria Lipman speaks with Russian China experts Vita Spivak and Alexander Gabuev about the February meeting between Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping, and what it may tell us about where the Russian-Chinese relationship is headed.
  • Exploring the Russian Courts' Ruling to Liquidate the Memorial Society January 28, 2022
    In this week’s PONARS Eurasia Podcast, Maria Lipman chats with scholars Kelly Smith and Benjamin Nathans about the history, achievements, and impending shutdown of the Memorial Society, Russia's oldest and most venerable civic organization, and what its imminent liquidation portends for the Russian civil society.
  • Russia's 2021 census and the Kremlin's nationalities policy [Lipman Series 2021] December 9, 2021
    In this week’s PONARS Eurasia Podcast, Maria Lipman chats with social scientist Andrey Shcherbak about the quality of the data collected in the recent population census and the goals of Vladimir Putin's government's nationalities policy
  • Active citizens of any kind are under threat [Lipman Series 2021] November 5, 2021
    In this week’s PONARS Eurasia Podcast, Maria Lipman chats with Alexander Verkhovsky about the Kremlin's ever expanding toolkit against political and civic activists, journalists, and other dissidents.
  • Russia's Legislative Elections followup [Lipman Series 2021] October 4, 2021
    In this week’s PONARS Eurasia Podcast, Maria Lipman chats with Tanya Lokot and Nikolay Petrov about the results of Russia’s legislative elections and about what comes next.
  • Why Is the Kremlin Nervous? [Lipman Series 2021] September 14, 2021
    In this week’s PONARS Eurasia Podcast, Maria Lipman chats with Ben Noble and Nikolay Petrov about Russia’s September 17-19 legislative elections, repressive measures against electoral challengers, and whether to expect anything other than preordained results.
  • Vaccine Hesitancy in Russia, France, and the United States [Lipman Series 2021] August 31, 2021
    In this week's PONARS Eurasia Podcast episode, Maria Lipman chats with Denis Volkov, Naira Davlashyan, and Peter Slevin about why COVID-19 vaccination rates are still so low across the globe, comparing vaccine hesitant constituencies across Russia, France, and the United States.  
  • Is Russia Becoming More Soviet? [Lipman Series 2021] July 26, 2021
      In a new PONARS Eurasia Podcast episode, Maria Lipman chats with Maxim Trudolyubov about the current tightening of the Russian political sphere, asking whether or not it’s helpful to draw comparisons to the late Soviet period.
  • The Evolution of Russia's Political Regime [Lipman Series 2021] June 21, 2021
    In this week's episode of the PONARS Eurasia Podcast, Maria Lipman chats with Grigory Golosov and Henry Hale about the evolution of Russia's political regime, and what to expect in the lead-up to September's Duma elections.
  • Volodymyr Zelensky: Year Two [Lipman Series 2021] May 24, 2021
    In this week's episode of the PONARS Eurasia Podcast, Maria Lipman chats with Sergiy Kudelia and Georgiy Kasianov about Ukrainian President Zelensky's second year in office, and how he has handled the political turbulence of the past year.
  • Commentary | Комментарии

Commemorating the War: Is Glorification Without Hysteria Possible?

  • May 7, 2015
  • Andrey Makarychev

There is one notorious paradox deeply entrenched in the ardent debates about Russia’s May 9th celebration marking the 70th anniversary of World War II. While Russia is eager to use the victory narrative of the Great Patriotic War for justifying its “natural” belongingness to Europe, the opposite effect is being achieved: the Kremlin line is actually alienating Russia from the West, and the EU in particular.

The key element of the growing disconnection is not the malicious attempt of ill-wishing Russophobes to falsify history. The problem is much deeper, and it contains two interrelated facets.

First, Russia’s hegemonic discourse, enmeshed in the total glorification of Russian history, cannot accept that there might be other ways of commemorating the past – ways different from massive military parades and heavy, ceremonial mourning. It goes without saying that the Russian state is absolutely against leaving this delicate sphere up to citizens themselves to decide what is appropriate and or not.

The general movement from Russian officialdom is “discipline and punish.” A group of young Russian dancers were recently arrested for a twerking dance performance in front of the World War II Memorial in Novorossiysk. Their actions were deemed “illegal.” There was a similar incident when a school dance group in Orenburg twerked in a show that had some colors of the St. George ribbon, one of the most popular symbols of Russia’s military glory. And in Tatarstan, prosecutors opened an investigation into “Dzalil,” an opera where the head of the local Communists spotted “direct parallels between Communism and fascism.”[1]

We see the creeping colonization of Russian political debate by theological discourse, with growing similarities between the two. It all started with the campaign to protect the “religious feelings of believers,” leading to episodes such as the imprisonment of Pussy Riot to the dismissal of a theatre director in Novosibirsk for staging “Tangeizer,” which had scenes that “insulted” some church-goers.

The question is whether Russian society can afford feelings other than official pomp and mourning as elements of memory politics. The answer is a severe “no.”

There was Russia’s fierce reaction to a recent Holocaust exhibition at the Tartu Art Museum (Estonia), which had some “ironic” items that Moscow interpreted as a mockery of the victims of fascism. Russia accused the Estonian and Polish exhibit organizers of sacrilege using the same, rigid, semantic framework consistent with Russia’s contemporary memory discourse. 

What this narrative categorically refuses to accept is that traumas can not only be bemoaned, but also overcome through emancipatory performances.

Take, for example, some of the “controversial” photos at the Tartu exhibit by Polish artist Zbigniew Libera. There is a depiction of a liberation from an extremely tragic experience through the gesture of life-asserting smiles.[2] There are scenes of dance performances by an elderly Holocaust survivor in front of concentration camps, with the symbolism being the victory of life over death, as projected by the artist's own idiom.[3]

Perhaps, a country whose intellectual traditions include the thoughts of renowned philosopher Mikhail Bakhtin, who said a lot about the stabilizing functions of “laughs” in society, could be more open to alternative means of memory and celebrating.

The second interrelated facet is that Russia seems unable to understand that for the “rehabilitation of fascism,” in particular in the Baltic states, a very different type of public attitude is required, one that could be dubbed the temporal othering of history. In other words, Russia wants to take history into its future, while Europe wishes to leave history in the past without making a morally-impossible choice, such as between two former dictatorships: Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union.

Two movies that came out recently in Estonia, “1944” and “The Fencer,” are narrative stories about war (and scars of war) that are exactly about attempts to conceptualize the distance that separates people from old traumas involving submission to a foreign power. Both Estonian films tell a story drastically different from Russia’s crafted take on history. The movies bewail the tragic splits that occurred within society, yet they refuse to judge from today’s perspective their old compatriots who, due to multiple and often contingent circumstances, fought not only against foreign occupiers, but also against each other.

It would be beneficial for Russia to at least try to understand this type of history-telling, to accept the legitimacy of other ways of remembering the past, to go beyond a simple, self-glorifying discourse – otherwise the boundary between exaltation and hysteria becomes even more blurred.

________________________________

[1] www.ura.ru/news/1052206998

[2] http://culture.pl/en/work/positives-zbigniew-libera

[3] http://tvrain.ru/articles/vyzhivshij_uznik_osventsima_stantseval_v_kontslage-386575/

 

Andrey Makarychev
Andrey Makarychev
Website | + posts
Visiting Professor

Affiliation

Johan Skytte Institute of Political Studies, University of Tartu, Estonia

Links

University of Tartu (Bio)

Expertise

Russian Foreign and Security Policies, EU-Russian Relations, Foreign Policy Discourses, Regionalism and Federalism
  • Andrey Makarychev
    https://www.ponarseurasia.org/members/andrey-makarychev/
    Georgian-Russian Relations: the Role of Discourses and Narratives
  • Andrey Makarychev
    https://www.ponarseurasia.org/members/andrey-makarychev/
    The Minsk–Khabarovsk nexus: Ethical, performative, corporeal
  • Andrey Makarychev
    https://www.ponarseurasia.org/members/andrey-makarychev/
    Twigg: I worry about whether or not people are going to be willing to take Sputnik V in Russia
  • Andrey Makarychev
    https://www.ponarseurasia.org/members/andrey-makarychev/
    Culture as an Instrument
Related Topics
  • Makarychev
Previous Article
  • Commentary | Комментарии

Годовщина Победы: возможен ли праздник без истерии?

  • May 7, 2015
  • Andrey Makarychev
View
Next Article
  • In the News | Hовости

Gorenburg: Russian military programs will keep running, but cuts or delays are inevitable

  • May 7, 2015
  • PONARS Eurasia
View
You May Also Like
View
  • Commentary | Комментарии
  • Recommended | Рекомендуем
  • Territorial Conflict

Dominating Ukraine’s Sky

  • Volodymyr Dubovyk
  • March 5, 2022
View
  • Commentary | Комментарии
  • Recommended | Рекомендуем

Russian Anti-War Protests and the State’s Response

  • Lauren McCarthy
  • March 4, 2022
View
  • Commentary | Комментарии

Путин и Лукашенко

  • Konstantin Sonin
  • August 29, 2020
View
  • Commentary | Комментарии

Отравление оппозиционеров в России превратилось в регулярную практику

  • Vladimir Gelman
  • August 22, 2020
View
  • Commentary | Комментарии

Авторитарные режимы не вечны: О ситуации в Белоруссии

  • Vladimir Gelman
  • August 14, 2020
View
  • Commentary | Комментарии

В Беларуси пока что все идет по российскому сценарию

  • Olexiy Haran
  • August 12, 2020
View
  • Commentary | Комментарии

Опасная игра Лукашенко

  • Pavel Baev
  • August 11, 2020
View
  • Commentary | Комментарии

Власть справилась

  • Sergei Medvedev
  • August 10, 2020

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

PONARS Eurasia
  • About
  • Membership
  • Policy Memos
  • Recommended
  • Events
Powered by narva.io

Permissions & Citation Guidelines

Input your search keywords and press Enter.